A nontrivial ring with unit eliminates imaginaries just in case its complete theory has the following property: every definable m-ary equivalence relation E may be defined by a formula f = f, where f is an m-ary definable function. We show that for certain natural expansions of the field of p-adic numbers, elimination of imaginaries fails or is independent of ZPC. Similar results hold for certain fields of formal power series.

The main result of this paper is a transfer theorem which describes the relationship between constructive validity and classical validity for a class of first-order sentences over the p-adics. The proof of one direction of the theorem uses a principle of intuitionism; the proof of the other direction is classically valid. Constructive verifications of known properties of the p-adics are indicated. In particular, the existence of cylindric algebraic decompositions for the p-adics is used.