A Situationalist Solution to the Ship of Theseus Puzzle

Erkenntnis 81 (5):973-992 (2016)
Download Edit this record How to cite View on PhilPapers
This paper outlines a novel solution to the Ship of Theseus puzzle. The solution relies on situations, a philosophical tool used in natural language semantics among other places. The core idea is that what is true is always relative to the situation under consideration. I begin by outlining the problem before briefly introducing situations. I then present the solution: in smaller situations the candidate is identical to Theseus’s ship. But in larger situations containing both candidates these identities are neither true nor false. Finally, I discuss some worries for the view that arise from the nature of identity, and suggest responses. It is concluded that the solution, and the theory that underpins it, are worth further investigation.
PhilPapers/Archive ID
Revision history
First archival date: 2018-09-11
Latest version: 2 (2018-09-11)
View upload history
References found in this work BETA
Modal Logic as Metaphysics.Williamson, Timothy
Situations and Attitudes.Barwise, Jon & Perry, John
Reference and Essence.Salmon, Nathan U.

View all 15 references / Add more references

Citations of this work BETA
The Ship of Theseus Puzzle.Rose, David; Machery, Edouard; Stich, Stephen; Alai, Mario; Angelucci, Adriano; Berniūnas, Renatas; E. Buchtel, Emma; Chatterjee, Amita; Cheon, Hyundeuk; Cho, In-Rae; Cohnitz, Daniel; Cova, Florian; Dranseika, Vilius; Lagos, Angeles Eraña; Ghadakpour, Laleh; Grinberg, Maurice; Hannikainen, Ivar; Hashimoto, Takaaki; Horowitz, Amir; Hristova, Evgeniya; Jraissati, Yasmina; Kadreva, Veselina; Karasawa, Kaori; Kim, Hackjin; Kim, Yeonjeong; Lee, Min-Woo; Mauro, Carlos; Mizumoto, Masaharu; Moruzzi, Sebastiano; Y. Olivola, Christopher; Ornelas, Jorge; Osimani, Barbara; Rosas, Alejandro; Romero, Carlos; Sangoi, Massimo; Sereni, Andrea; Songhorian, Sarah; Sousa, Paulo; Struchiner, Noel; Tripodi, Vera; Usui, Naoki; Vázquez Del Mercado, Alejandro Vázquez Del; Volpe, Giorgio; Vosgerichian, Hrag A.; Zhang, Xueyi & Zhu, Jing
Modelling Deep Indeterminacy.Darby, George & Pickup, Martin
Deep Indeterminacy in Physics and Fiction.Darby, George; Pickup, Martin & Robson, Jon

Add more citations

Added to PP index

Total views
144 ( #20,351 of 41,492 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
31 ( #19,551 of 41,492 )

How can I increase my downloads?

Downloads since first upload
This graph includes both downloads from PhilArchive and clicks to external links.