In this article, I aim to do two things: first, introduce Juche, the official philosophy of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (“North Korea”), and second, defend Juche against Alzo David-West’s allegation that it is a nonsensical philosophy. I organize David-West’s complaints into two major strands—that Juche’s axiom is too vague to be of philosophical use and that Juche makes too stark a distinction between human vs. everything else—and offer responses to both strands. My goal isn’t (...) to defend the regime, but to present its ideology in the most charitable way so its merits and demerits can be seen more clearly in future engagements. (shrink)

There is ongoing debate on whether Juche (주체/主體), the North Korean state ideology, is indigenous, Marxist-Leninist, or Confucian—or if it’s a real philosophy at all. In this article, I introduce Juche and show how characteristics that philosophers identify to be unique or pronounced in premodern Korean philosophy can be found in Juche as well. Intellectual adaptation, pragmaticism, and an emphasis on continual improvement are prominent in both premodern Korean thought and Juche. Juche should be understood (...) as a politically inflected outgrowth that is embedded within the larger context of Korean philosophy. (shrink)

Can a Country Survive Without Importation? -/- In theory, a country could strive for complete self-sufficiency, producing all of its own goods and resources without relying on imports. However, in practice, achieving total economic independence is extremely difficult due to several key factors. While some nations have attempted to minimize reliance on imports, history and modern economic realities show that complete self-sufficiency often leads to inefficiencies and stagnation. -/- Challenges of Total Economic Independence -/- 1. Natural Resource Limitations -/- One (...) of the primary obstacles to self-sufficiency is the unequal distribution of natural resources. Some countries lack essential raw materials such as oil, rare minerals, or even fertile land for agricultural production. For example, nations in the Middle East are rich in oil but rely on imports for food, while Japan, despite its advanced economy, must import energy resources due to limited domestic reserves. -/- 2. Technological Constraints -/- Modern industries rely on a complex global supply chain. The production of high-tech goods, such as semiconductors, requires raw materials and specialized components that often come from different parts of the world. Even if a country has the capability to manufacture everything domestically, it may not have access to the necessary raw materials without imports. -/- 3. Economic Efficiency and Cost Considerations -/- Self-sufficiency can lead to inefficiency and higher costs. Some products are cheaper and better produced in certain regions due to factors like climate, labor costs, or expertise. For instance, tropical fruits are more efficiently grown in equatorial countries, while colder regions focus on other agricultural products. By engaging in trade, countries can allocate their resources more efficiently and focus on industries where they have a comparative advantage. -/- 4. Workforce Specialization and Innovation -/- A modern economy thrives on specialization. If a country attempts to produce everything domestically, it may struggle with quality and innovation. International trade allows access to cutting-edge technology, research, and skilled labor that might not be available within a single nation. Countries that isolate themselves often fall behind in technological advancements. -/- 5. Global Economic Interdependence -/- The world economy is deeply interconnected. Countries that refuse to engage in trade may experience slower economic growth and reduced development. Trade fosters economic relationships, diplomatic ties, and mutual support during crises. Relying solely on domestic production may also leave a country vulnerable to natural disasters or unforeseen disruptions in critical industries. -/- 6. Cultural and Consumer Preferences -/- Consumers often demand products that cannot be produced locally. Items such as exotic foods, luxury goods, or the latest technology may not be available without imports. Restricting trade could lead to lower living standards, as citizens would have fewer choices and potentially higher prices for locally made alternatives. -/- Examples of Self-Sufficiency Attempts -/- Some nations have attempted self-reliance, but their experiences highlight the difficulties of total economic independence: -/- North Korea follows the ideology of Juche (self-reliance), but its economy struggles due to a lack of imports, leading to food shortages and limited technological advancement. -/- The Soviet Union attempted a closed economy but still relied on trade for certain goods, particularly agricultural products. -/- Small island nations often have no choice but to import food, fuel, and technology due to limited land and resources. -/- Is Partial Self-Sufficiency Possible? -/- While total self-sufficiency is impractical, many countries strive for partial self-sufficiency in key areas such as food, energy, and defense. Some examples include: -/- Russia and China have invested in domestic agriculture and technology to reduce reliance on Western imports. -/- Japan prioritizes food security and renewable energy projects to enhance self-reliance. -/- The United States and European Union promote local manufacturing in strategic sectors such as semiconductors and pharmaceuticals to reduce dependency on foreign suppliers. -/- Conclusion -/- While a country may attempt to become self-sufficient, complete independence from imports is nearly impossible in today’s interconnected world. Instead, a balanced approach—where nations produce essential goods locally while engaging in strategic trade—offers the most sustainable and efficient solution. By focusing on self-sufficiency in critical areas while benefiting from global trade, countries can enhance their economic stability and resilience without sacrificing growth and innovation. -/- . (shrink)