I could summarise Being There unkindly, but not too inaccurately, as “Language of thought: bad. Everything else: good”. For the book is a fast and approving tour of a menagerie of alternatives to the classic computational theory of the mind. Some of the usual suspects appear— neural nets, connectionism—but they are not interrogated as deeply as the new members of the gang. For example, Clark walks us through some interesting new ideas in neuroscience. But none of the gang are pressed (...) very hard. Clark sketches a lot of interesting ideas but “sketches” is the right word. This is a book for the already sympathetic. For none of the examples are developed in the detail that would be required to convince a sceptic. A second issue concerns integration. Clark develops a number of themes as the book unwinds, but by the conclusion I was still uncertain about the extent to which the ideas in Being There are intended to be a package deal. (shrink)