Dissertation, Princeton University (
2023)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
This dissertation investigates Plato’s prohibition on suicide at Phaedo 62b2-c9. I first lift
two descriptions of death early in the text. At Phaedo 64c, Plato offers a description of physical
death. A person dies physically when their body falls away from their soul. Plato goes on to offer
a description of psychological death at 67c-d. A person dies psychologically when their soul has
unencumbered itself from the body as much as is possible. Generally, I conclude, death is the
separation of the soul and body from one another. Having determined what death is for Plato, I
turn to the central topic of the dissertation, Plato’s prohibition on suicide. I suggest that the
suicide prohibition consists of two parts. The Enclosure Argument indicates the body is an
enclosure from which we should not seek freedom so as not to defy the gods. The Guardian
Argument indicates that we humans should not kill ourselves because we are enslaved to the
gods. In all, the two arguments cohere insofar as they both tell against abandoning right rule.